Agenda and minutes

Standards (This Committee has now been combined with Audit and Governance and no longer meets) - Wednesday, 30th June, 2010 7.00 pm

Venue: Town Hall

Contact: Denise Sunman 

No. Item



To receive the apologies of any Member who is unable to attend this meeting.


Apologies for absence were received on behalf of Borough Councillor William Norton and Parish Councillor Louisa Venables.



Declarations of Interest

To invite Councillors to declare any interests they may have in items on the agenda.


There were no declarations of interest.




To confirm as a correct record the minutes of the meeting of the Standards Committee held on 8th December 2009.


(Minutes attached)




the minutes of the meeting of the Standards Committee held on 8th December 2010 be agreed as a correct record and signed by the Chair.


Monitoring Officer's Report

To receive a report from the Monitoring Officer on any matters of relevance to the Committee.


(Report attached)


The Monitoring Officer presented a report on matters of relevance to the Committee for the consideration of the Members.


The training of Members was discussed. It was confirmed that new Members had, as far as was possible, received induction training soon after election in issues including the Members’ Code of Conduct. It was anticipated that the Standards Committee and Monitoring Officer would have an opportunity to address the perceived training needs of Members in respect of standards and the Code of Conduct  through the Member Development Steering Group.


The Committee took the view that training in the broadest sense should be play a key role in the life of all Members and should be an ongoing process throughout their time on the Council. Officers proposed that Members should be offered a rounded package which provides a choice of content and learning styles.


In respect of training directed at Standards Committee members, it was agreed that this was best delivered in bite-sized chunks, particularly in the light of the prospective changes coming through at the present time regarding the future of Standards for England (SfE) regime.


It was noted that Members might benefit from further training in their proper role in the adoption of the Statement of Accounts. Officers agreed to refer this suggestion to the Director of Finance and Resources.


The Monitoring Officer provided an update on the investigation into an ongoing complaint against a Member (reference 01/2010). It was noted that the final report was nearing completion. Officers undertook to keep Members abreast of the developments in ongoing investigations as the process largely took place behind the scenes and the impression could be formed that matters were not progressing. Members commented that an enhanced minimum provision of IT equipment would assist in realising this aspiration. It was stated that this would be on the agenda for the next meeting of the Modernising Democracy Steering Group.




1)         the first report of the Monitoring Officer be noted;


2)         a Monitoring Officer’s report be submitted to each subsequent meeting of the Committee; and


3)         the approach to Standards Committee Members’ training, as outlined above, be agreed;




Members' Planning Code of Good Practice

To consider a revised Planning Code of Good Practice for adoption by the Council.


Please note that this draft Code is being re-submitted to the Committee following consideration by the Planning Committee.


Additions to the draft Code are marked in bold and highlighted and deletions are marked by strikethrough.


(Report attached)


The Committee received the Members’ Planning Code of Good Practice on a second occasion following deliberation of the document by the Planning Committee.


The changes that had been proposed were welcomed, although one further amendment was proposed in respect of speaking rights of Ward / Local Members.




the draft Members’ Planning Code of Good Conduct, as amended (attached), be adopted, subject to the following further amendment:


Paragraph 3, Bullet Point 3 – if Ward Members wish to exercise their speaking rights as Ward Councillors on any item they should remove themselves from the decision-making process for the duration of that item.


Chair's / Members' Reports

To consider any Chair / Member updates not separately covered on the agenda list, including brief feedback from any Seminars or Conferences.


(Oral report)


Members provided a brief resume of the Council’s meetings at which they had acted as observers on behalf of the Standards Committee.




the report be noted.


Parish Council Report (if any)

To consider any report from the Feckenham Parish Council’s representatives on any matters of relevance to the Committee.


(Oral report)


The Parish Council representative informed the Committee that the Parish Council was at present carrying two vacancies.




the report be noted.



To note any publications which the Committee may find of interest.


(No separate report)


There were no recent publications to which the Monitoring Officer wished to draw Members’ attention.



Work Programme

To consider and review the Committee’s Work Programme.


(Report attached)


Members considered the Committee Work Programme for future meetings. It was noted at the outset that a number of the matters included may be held over pending any changes made nationally to the Standards regime during the autumn of 2010.


The inclusion of Criminal Records Bureau (CRB) checks for Councillors was discussed, with some uncertainty being apparent as to the nature of the Committee’s interest in this matter. Officers undertook to obtain information on the prevalence of mandatory CRB checks undertaken by other Council’s within the region.


Given that there were now two ongoing complaints, it was proposed that guidance from the Ethical Standards Officer of Bromsgrove District Council would be a useful addition to Members’ training. It was agreed that this might be provided prior to pre-hearing and hearing, if required, for complaint reference 01/2010.




the work programme for the Committee be noted, subject to the comments, above.

Members Planning Code of Good Practice Appendix - Post-Standards